WBR quality checklist: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
{{Board review project}}
{{Board review project}}
[[Image:Main_help_page_small.PNG|100px|link=Help]][[Image:Projects.PNG|100px|link=Projects]][[Image:Editor's_Tools.PNG|100px|link=Help Menu]]
[[Image:Main_help_page_small.PNG|100px|link=Help]][[Image:Projects.PNG|100px|link=Projects]][[Image:Editor's_Tools.PNG|100px|link=Help Menu]]
{{CMG}}; {{AE}} [[User:Gonzalo Romero|Gonzalo A. Romero, M.D.]]
'''Editor-In-Chief:''' [[User:William J Gibson|Will Gibson]]; {{AE}} [[User:Gonzalo Romero|Gonzalo A. Romero, M.D.]][mailto:gromero@wikidoc.org];{{Rim}};[[User:Sergekorjian|Serge Korjian]]; [[User:YazanDaaboul|Yazan Daaboul]]; {{VR}}; {{M.P}}; {{AO}}; {{MS}};
==Overview==
The goal of the Board Review Questions Project is to create a universally accessible free repository of Board Review Questions which are targeted at multiple educational levels. All questions must be original and cannot violate Wikidoc's strict policies regarding plagiarism.  Liability related to copyright violations regarding board review questions rests with the person who prepared the question. Please notify WikiDoc in writing if you feel that there has been a copyright violation regarding a board review question.  Board review questions are reviewed and discussed by the WikiDoc Scholars on Monday mornings at 10:30 AM Eastern time. After creating the questions, the editor must quality check his or her own work using the following '''WBR quality checklist'''.  Board review questions must be approved by the WBR Editors-in-Chief prior to uploading them onto the WikiDoc site. 
<br>


==WBR Quality Checklist==
==WBR Quality Checklist==
{|style="width:70%; height:100px" border="1"
{|style="width:70%; height:100px" border="1" align=center
|style="height:100px"; style="width:25%" border="1" bgcolor="SkyBlue" | '''Standard'''
|style="height:100px"; style="width:25%" border="1" bgcolor="DodgerBlue" align=center| '''Standard'''
|style="height:100px"; style="width:75%" border="1" bgcolor="NavajoWhite" | '''Items'''  
|style="height:100px"; style="width:75%" border="1" bgcolor="SandyBrown" align=center| '''Items'''  
|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''1. Correct Classification'''
|align=center| '''1. Correct Classification'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Board  level  
* Board  level  
* Subject/Category
* Subject/Category
Line 20: Line 17:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
 
| '''2. Question Stem/Prompt'''
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|align=center| '''2. Question Stem/Prompt'''
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* '''Logical order in clinical cases:'''  age  and gender → chief  complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
* '''Logical order in clinical cases:'''  age  and gender → chief  complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
* Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)? {{Main|  How to create a board review question#USMLE Step 1 Question Format}}
* Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)? {{Main|  How to create a board review question#USMLE Step 1 Question Format}}
Line 30: Line 28:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''3. Answer Choices'''
|align=center| '''3. Answer Choices'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Clear  distractors
* Clear  distractors
*  [[Images|Image]] for each answer choice  
*  [[Images|Image]] for each answer choice  
Line 39: Line 37:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''4. Overall Explanation'''
|align=center| '''4. Overall Explanation'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and  negatives)
* Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and  negatives)
* Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
* Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
Line 51: Line 49:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''5. Answer Choices Explanations'''
|align=center| '''5. Answer Choices Explanations'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Correct answer: summarized relevant info  
* Correct answer: summarized relevant info  
* Incorrect choice ___ explanation  
* Incorrect choice ___ explanation  
Line 64: Line 62:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''6. Promoting WikiDoc Use'''
|align=center| '''6. Promoting WikiDoc Use'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Used WikiDoc info
* Used WikiDoc info
* Used relevant working [[links|hyperlinks]]
* Used relevant working [[links|hyperlinks]]
Line 72: Line 70:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''7. English'''
|align=center| '''7. English'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Question Format
* Question Format
* Grammar
* Grammar
Line 84: Line 82:


|-bgcolor="LightSalmon"
|-bgcolor="LightSalmon"
| '''8. References'''
|align=center| '''8. References'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Cited  used [[References|references]]
* Cited  used [[References|references]]
* Respected [[Copyright]] sources and [[How to avoid plagiarism|'''avoided plagiarism''']]
* Respected [[Copyright]] sources and [[How to avoid plagiarism|'''avoided plagiarism''']]
Line 91: Line 89:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''9. Creativity'''
|align=center| '''9. Creativity'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Visual materials
* Visual materials
* [[Medical Mnemonics for Examinations|WikiDoc-Mnemonic]]
* [[Medical Mnemonics for Examinations|WikiDoc-Mnemonic]]
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
| '''10. Include into the WBR Question List'''
|align=center| '''10. Include into the WBR Question List'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Included question into list of questions [[WBR]]
* Included question into list of questions [[WBR]]
* Correct classification for board level  
* Correct classification for board level  
Line 112: Line 110:
|}
|}


{{See also|How to create a board review question|Category:WBRQuestion}}
===WikiDoc Links===
 
===Other WikiDoc Links===
* [[MCAT]]
* [[MCAT]]
* [[USMLE Step 1]]
* [[USMLE Step 1]]
Line 123: Line 119:
* [[How to upload USMLE II Images]]
* [[How to upload USMLE II Images]]
* [[COMLEX-USA]]
* [[COMLEX-USA]]
<br>
{{See also|How to create a board review question|Category:WBRQuestion}}

Latest revision as of 22:23, 31 January 2014

WikiDoc Board Review
The Project
The Team
Guidelines
Question List
Quality Checklist
Medical Illustrations
Question Template
High Yield!
Normal Labs
Mnemonics
Test Taking Tips
Resources

Editor-In-Chief: Will Gibson; Associate Editor(s)-in-Chief: Gonzalo A. Romero, M.D.[1];Rim Halaby, M.D. [2];Serge Korjian; Yazan Daaboul; Vendhan Ramanujam M.B.B.S [3]; Mugilan Poongkunran M.B.B.S [4]; Ayokunle Olubaniyi, M.B,B.S [5]; Mahmoud Sakr, M.D. [6];

WBR Quality Checklist

Standard Items
1. Correct Classification
  • Board level
  • Subject/Category
  • System/sub-category
  • High yield topic (frequently tested)
2. Question Stem/Prompt
  • Logical order in clinical cases: age and gender → chief complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
  • Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)?
    Main article: How to create a board review question § USMLE Step 1 Question Format
  • Jump question
  • Image in stem (CXR/CT/MRI, biopsy, graph, microscopy)
  • Question length: short (1-2 lines), medium (3-4 lines), long (>4 lines)
3. Answer Choices
  • Clear distractors
  • Image for each answer choice
  • Use of current guidelines/algorithms
  • Answer choice placement
4. Overall Explanation
  • Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and negatives)
  • Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
  • High yield content
  • Educational objective (1 or 2 take-home sentences/phrases)
  • WikiDoc-Mnemonic: own & unique or from common source (FA 2014)
  • Working hyperlinks to relevant info
  • Medical thinking
5. Answer Choices Explanations
  • Correct answer: summarized relevant info
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Appropriate length
  • High yield facts
  • Working hyperlinks to relevant info
6. Promoting WikiDoc Use
7. English
  • Question Format
  • Grammar
  • Case story-telling
  • Punctuation
  • Word choice
  • Correct medical abbreviations from USMLE.org (i.e. for vital signs, labs, images)
8. References
9. Creativity
10. Include into the WBR Question List
  • Included question into list of questions WBR
  • Correct classification for board level
  • Working hyperlinks to WBR0____
  • Correct classification for subject/Category
  • Correct classification for system/sub-category
  • Correct classification for High-Yield
  • Correct classification for keywords
  • Correct classification for author

WikiDoc Links


See also: How to create a board review question and Category:WBRQuestion
Retrieved from "https://www.wikidoc.org/index.php?title=WBR_quality_checklist&oldid=936850"